The Greatest Impostor in History: the baronet butcher of Wagga Wagga
by M. Maddison and E. Rurenga

The letters forming the words "Sir Roger Doughty Tichborne, Baronet" may be transposed without addition of omission into the sentence 'You horrid butcher Orton, biggest rascal [sic] here' Amador Weekly Ledger, Jackson California, 16 May 1874

The Wagga Wagga of 1865 was a small provincial town in the Riverina, with a population of approximately 1,000. Today, Wagga Wagga, with a population of over 57,000 is the largest inland city in N.S.W and the place of the Wiradjuri Aboriginal people.

Nestled on the banks of the Murrumbidgee River, Wagga Wagga takes its name from the Wiradjuri word Waagan (crow) which, when repeated can be translated as "the place where crows assemble in large numbers".

However, it was one hundred and forty years ago that a single infamous episode brought Wagga to the world's attention. Tom Castro was a butcher plying his trade off Fitzmaurice Street, in Wagga's central business district. A stout, uncouth man, described by one customer as "loose and slommicking", Castro and his supporters set in motion one of the greatest cases of disputed identity in modern history.

In 1854, Roger Charles Doughty Tichborne, heir to the extensive Tichborne Estates in Hampshire, England vanished en route from Rio de Janeiro to New York. An inquest was held, and the ship Bella, her passenger and crew were officially declared lost at sea, bringing Roger's young life to a premature end. After the disappearance of Roger's ship, his mother Lady Tichborne refused to believe that her son was dead.

Eleven years later, in 1865, Lady Tichborne received a letter from Mr Cubitt's Missing Friends Office in Sydney. A Wagga based attorney, William Gibbes had written them a letter claiming that one of his clients, a man named Thomas Castro, was Tichborne living incognito.

The "Claimant" as he became known, and the question of his true identity, grew to be a cause célèbre in the English speaking world. Eventually leading to two court trials - one civil, and one for perjury - the trial lasted 291 days, involved 36,000 cross examination questions and defence council speeches that lasted months.

Even the sending of special commissions to Australia and Chile failed to prove to everyone's satisfaction whether the Tichborne Claimant was a butcher from Wapping, London (a man called Arthur Orton, using the Antipodean alias of Tom Castro) or truly the heir to the Hampshire Estates.

The Museum of the Riverina and the Wagga Wagga City Library both have small but significant collections which relate to this moment in history, during which Wagga featured on the world stage.

Souvenirs including figurines, glassware, pamphlets, postcards and the infamous Tichborne bonds were mass-manufactured for the duration of the trial. Souvenir figurines depicting key personalities of the trial were churned out for the well-off and working-class alike. Cheap figurines were manufactured using materials ranging from painted and unpainted plaster, earthenware and terracotta.

For the wealthier collector, china and porcelain statuettes were created. A Staffordshire figurine of Orton is reputedly kept at the Prime Ministers residence, Kirribilli House.

In 1984 Wagga Wagga City Council received a donation of a set of four Tichborne Trial figurines. The donor's wife was the great granddaughter of William Gibbes, the aforementioned lawyer with a practice in Wagga during the 19th century, and the Attorney for Tom Castro.

These particular figurines (originally a set of six) had been manufactured and sold in London at the time of the Trial to help defray the legal costs of the defendant. These figurines can be viewed as part of the permanent displays exhibited at the
Museum of the Riverina

Roger Doughty Tichborne
as a young man

Wagga Wagga City Council Library - Local Studies collection


 



Tichborne Trial figurines
Sergeant, Dowager Lady Tichborne, the Claimant and the Solicitor General
c. 1870s

Museum of the Riverina
Wagga Wagga


Accommodation
Wagga Wagga
Heritage Motor Inn  

The centrepiece of Wagga's Tichborne collection is Nathan Hughes' oil painting titled The Great Tichborne Trial, which hangs in the Historic Council Chambers. Painted in 1874, and measuring 6 foot by 8 foot, it depicts a scene during the address for the defence by Dr. Keneally, the Counsel for the Defence. The Claimant himself is seated in the foreground, and such details including the table cut to fit the great corpulence of the Claimant have been faithfully represented by the artist.

This painting was originally the piece de resistance furnishing Earlsbrae Hall, the family home of E.W. Cole (of the Book Arcade fame). In a massive gilt frame, and including a key to the personalities depicted, the painting had been exhibited all over the world: an admission charge of 1-/ earning £14,000 in revenue. Visited by thousands, and commanding the praise and admiration of all who saw it, it was presented to Wagga City Council in 1953 by Edward H. Kinnear, Esq., of Essendon, Victoria.

Hanging next to the painting is a framed photograph captioned Original Photo of the Jury - Tichborne Trial (the only known photo). Arthur Orton Sentence 14 Years 1874 - Law Costs 92,000 Pounds. On display at the Museum of the Riverina's Botanic Gardens Site is the full set of bound volumes entitled The Trial at Bar of Sir Roger C.D. Tichborne, Bart, in the Court of Queen's Bench at Westminster…, 1873. Within the collection are also some contemporary photographs and a souvenir postcard. The Museum has also recently acquired a contemporary oil painting by H. Williams, titled Butcher Shop, Wagga Wagga, c. 1841.

The Tichborne figurines and other pieces of "Tichborneiana" existing today are tangible representations of the fascination which this case created internationally. They are a physical embodiment of the enthralled excitement and interest which was generated amongst the public at large - an interest which is still being generated today.

In total, the Claimant endured years of trial, ten years of penal servitude following, culminating in twelve years miserable obscurity. He died on All Fool's Day 1898, and was buried in an unmarked grave at Paddington Cemetery in London, with the name Sir Roger Doughty Tichborne defiantly engraved across his coffin.

To this day, the question remains unanswered - could any impostor have had such stamina?

Bibliography:
Robyn Annear, The Man Who Lost Himself: The Unbelievable Story of the Tichborne Claimant, Text Publishing, Melbourne 2002
Stuart Kind, 'Criminal Identification', in Science Against Crime, London, 1982 p. 24

Museum of the Riverina - Wagga Wagga NSW
Article and images supplied by Michelle A. Maddison
Curator - Museum of the Riverina - Wagga Wagga


Travel Insurance


Attractions, accommodation, heritage, natural, indigenous, tours, cultural & ecotourism

Project - Heritage Walks and Tours - Museums - Car Rental
Discovery NSW - NSW Accommodation - Enquires
Home